convert

Summary

If a hypothesis h is nearly but not quite equal to your goal, then exact h will fail, because theorem provers are fussy about details. But convert h might well succeed, and leave you instead with goals corresponding to the places where h and the goal did not quite match up.

Examples

Here the hypothesis h is really close to the goal; the only difference is that one has a d and the other has an e. If you already have a proof hde : d = e then you can rw hde at h and then exact h will close the goal. But if you don’t have this proof to hand and would like Lean to reduce the goal to d = e then convert is exactly the tactic you want.

import data.real.basic

example (a b c d e : ℝ) (f : ℝ → ℝ) (h : f (a + b) + f (c + d) = 37) :
  f(a + b) + f(c + e) = 37 :=
begin
  convert h,
  -- ⊢ e = d
  sorry
end

Sometimes convert can go too far. For example consider the following (provable) goal:

a b c d e : ℝ
f : ℝ → ℝ
h : f (a + b) + f (c + d) = 37
⊢ f (a + b) + f (d + c) = 37

If you try convert h you will be left with two goals ⊢ d = c and ⊢ c = d (and these goals are perhaps not provable). You can probably guess what happened; convert was too eager. You can “tone convert down” with convert h using 2 or some other appropriate small number, to tell it when to stop converting. Experiment with the number to get it right. Here is an example.

import data.real.basic

example (a b c d e : ℝ) (f : ℝ → ℝ) (h : f (a + b) + f (c + d) = 37) :
  f(a + b) + f(d + c) = 37 :=
begin
  convert h using 3,
  -- ⊢ d + c = c + d
  ring,
end